Roundtable in Kyiv. Decriminalisation of sex work in Ukraine: problems, challenges of war and ways to overcome them

Сomments:0

On 12 August 2024, a roundtable discussion ‘Decriminalisation of sex work in Ukraine: problems, challenges of the war and ways to overcome them’ was held in Kyiv with the participation of government officials, civil society representatives and leading experts.

Organisers and Partners: CO ‘Legalife-Ukraine’, CO ‘100% LIFE’, BRDO (Better Regulation Delivery Office), CO "VOLNA" and others.

Today, the rights of sex workers of Ukraine to freedom of association, freedom from violence, freedom from discrimination, health, work, and privacy are systematically violated.

Experts estimate that there were about 80,000 sex workers in Ukraine before the war. In peacetime, sex work was one of the few available ways to earn a living, especially for women who did not have access to education. The war, displacement, destruction and economic decline caused by the war left many women homeless and without income, which could push them to provide sex services for any reward: food, medicine, housing. During the active hostilities, most sex workers in Ukraine also lost their jobs, and thus, access to the necessary resources: water, food, housing, etc. This creates conditions for more risky sexual behaviour: sex workers are forced to agree to sex without a condom, risky sexual practices, drug use, etc.

At the same time, military operations and the unstable situation increase the risk of exploitation and trafficking. There are already reports of criminal gangs targeting Ukrainian women refugees fleeing the horrors of the Russian invasion.

Studies have shown that seven out of ten women experienced gender-based violence during the conflict. Sexual violence makes women more vulnerable to HIV infection, given the likelihood that perpetrators abuse victims without taking measures to protect them from STIs.

A UNFPA report on gender-based violence in the regions of eastern Ukraine, where the war with Russia has been ongoing since 2014, also confirms that women’s vulnerability to domestic violence has increased during the conflict. Reasons cited include the normalisation of a culture of violence in society, the wider availability of weapons, and the fragmentation of communities and loss of support networks.

There is a correlation between domestic violence and increased HIV prevalence, given that women fleeing domestic violence often find themselves in a vulnerable situation, without housing or economic security. Many victims also turn to harmful coping methods, such as substance abuse, to cope with the trauma. These factors make women susceptible to exploitation and forced prostitution, which increases their risk of HIV infection.

Gender-based violence is not only a cause of HIV, but also a consequence, and women and other marginalised genders are disproportionately affected by it. After diagnosis, the likelihood that HIV-positive Ukrainian women will experience violence (domestic and structural) increases by an average of 15.5%.

Fear and distrust of healthcare workers can lead women to conceal their diagnosis, depriving them of access to HIV treatment. Avoidance of health facilities also has life-threatening consequences for non-HIV-related medical problems. In an interview, one woman described how her fear of seeking medical care almost cost her life.

According to the organisers of the event, decriminalisation of sex work in Ukraine will contribute to a significant improvement in the human rights of this population.

The main issues that were proposed to the participants for study and discussion:

1. Decriminalisation of sex work in Ukraine: human rights or harm for public morality.

2. The cost of combating sex work for the budget and taxpayers.

3. Problems of judicial qualification of actions related to sex work and violation of the principles of legal certainty: threats to Ukraine at the international level.

4. Decriminalisation/legalisation of sex work in the light of Ukraine’s European integration.

5. World experience of decriminalisation of sex work and position of international organisations on decriminalisation of sex work.

6. Proposals for legislative regulation of sex work issues and further advocacy for the decriminalisation of porn in Ukraine.

During the discussions, human rights defenders, representatives of international organisations and government authorities discussed the challenges and problems associated with sex work in Ukraine, decriminalisation of such work and ways to legalise it, decriminalisation of porn as a separate sphere of sex work, problems of criminal justice in these issues and budget and taxpayer costs, international experience on these issues, and ways to make regulatory changes.

Anastasiia Serbina (Анастасія Сербіна), lawyer, consultant of the Expert Platform "Fight for Health" of the CO ‘100% Life’, gave a report on the financial burden caused to the criminal justice system in the process of investigating crimes in the field of commercial sex.

According to the expert’s analysis, the minimum cost of investigating and bringing one person to court is 8187 UAH of public funds. The cost of a trial of a sex worker is 27,753 hryvnias. And this does not even include such a shameful practice as prompt procurement of sex services by law enforcement officers, which also costs the state at least 1150 hryvnias per purchase, but according to experience, 2-3 such purchases are usually made.  Obviously, this money can be spent more rationally

Oksana Kashyntseva (Оксана Кашинцева), PhD in Law, consultant at the "Fight for Health" Expert Platform of the CO ‘100% Life’, shared the team’s achievements in the direction of advocacy and legislative work on the decriminalization of sex work and preventing interference in the private life of citizens.

Oksana emphasised that the group of lawyers preparing the decriminalisation laws has important tasks to perform: legalising sex work and preparing the relevant NACE - "nomenclature statistique des activités économiques dans la Communauté européenne"- Classifier of types of economic activity in Ukraine, as well as the preparation of regulations on the provision of social sex services to people with disabilities.

Iryna Yakovets (Ірина Яковець), Doctor of Law, consultant at the Expert Platform “Fight for Health” of the CO ‘100% LIFE’, spoke about gaps in definitions and unclear norms, the wording of which does not allow to clarify their meaning, and about human rights violations due to the free interpretation of these norms by law enforcement and judges.

An analysis of current case law shows that there is a lack of clarity in the understanding of the concepts of ‘brothel’ and ‘pimping’, as court decisions do not clearly define these categories. In their decisions, the judicial authorities usually limit themselves to general wording, such as ‘engaged in keeping a brothel and pandering for prostitution’. In a significant number of court decisions, pandering is understood as mediation in the provision of: a) sexual services; b) services of a sexual nature; c) services of an intimate nature; d) satisfaction of sexual needs. Again, there is no definition of what sexual/intimate/erotic services/needs/actions are.

This excludes the possibility of a single interpretation of the acts covered by the concept of ‘debauchery’, which is a gross violation of the principle of legal certainty in the formulation of a criminal law prohibition.

Denys Yevdokymenko (Денис Євдокименко), lawyer of the IT and Telecom sector at the BRDO’s (Better Regulation Delivery Office), stressed the need to renew and intensify joint efforts to advocate for the decriminalisation of porn in Ukraine.

Draft law 9623 on decriminalising the production, distribution and sale of pornographic materials was registered almost a year ago. Unfortunately, during this time, we are not aware of any consultations within the responsible Verkhovna Rada Committee or any other work. We also do not see any actions aimed at discussing the problem or the draft law by parliamentarians. At the same time, we see an increase in the number of criminal cases.

Nataliia Isaieva (Наталія Ісаєва), Director of CO ‘LEGALIFE-UKRAINE’, spoke about the risks faced by sex workers during the war, their needs and expectations from the introduction of decriminalisation of sex work in Ukraine.

Sex work is not human trafficking, it is a voluntary choice of an adult. Often, this choice is due to a difficult social and financial situation. It is for this choice that sex workers are deprived of support and assistance, discriminated against, stigmatised and exposed to violence.

Decriminalisation, i.e. the abolition of laws that punish CSW directly and indirectly, will enable sex workers to:

  • Reduce stigma;
  • Feel equal and more protected;
  • Get rid of fear and shame for their activities;
  • Freely seek help in case of violence;
  • Receive medical services without discrimination.

The event was made possible thanks to the support of our partners: SCALE, CO ‘100 PERCENT LIFE’ and the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria.

Team CO “Legalife-Ukraine”

Коментарів: 0