Сomments:0
When we talk about human rights, we often picture courts, high tribunals or complex laws. But for the average sex worker in Ukraine, the protection of rights begins not in court, but in an ordinary doctor’s office or during a conversation with a social worker.
Most of us are used to the fact that for the state, we are either ‘offenders’ (under Article 181-1 ‘Engaging in prostitution’ of the Code of Administrative Offences, which still provides for fine or invisible people who simply do not exist in official records. No one speaks openly about us, and we are not protected from violence. And when we come for help - to the hospital or to social services, we often face condemnation, fear of disclosing of our status, or simply a total misunderstanding of our real needs.
Our community of sex workers in Ukraine has conducted a large-scale study of current legislation. We analysed dozens of orders from the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Social Policy. The conclusion is grim: the system often pushes away those who need help the most.
THE SCALE OF THE PROBLEM IN NUMBERS
To understand why this is important, it is worth looking at the numbers. According to estimates by the Public Health Alliance and international organisations (such as UNAIDS), there are over 80,000 sex workers in Ukraine. This is a huge community of people who pay rent, buy groceries, raise children, and so on. But due to stigma and an outdated legal framework, most of these people remain completely unprotected.
According to sociological surveys within the community:
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE CURRENT LAWS?
The problem lies not only in the Administrative Code and fines. The problem runs much deeper — in so-called subordinate legislation (ministerial orders). It is these that determine exactly how doctors treat us in their surgeries and social workers in support centres.
As an analysis of the regulatory framework has shown, the situation is currently two-sided. On the one hand, there have been positive changes in terminology. On the other, there are still critically few real protection mechanisms.
The new regulations for 2023–2024 do indeed contain correct terminology, but they require substantial additions regarding protection mechanisms and the accessibility of services. To put it simply, the fact that we have started to be referred to as ‘people who provide sexual services’ rather than using offensive terms is a good thing. But simply changing the wording has not automatically improved the quality of care or safety.
The main gaps that currently exist
When analysing the current regulatory framework, community activists identified serious gaps:
MAIN BARRIERS AND THE COMMUNITY’S PROPOSALS
In addition to our criticisms, we are proposing amendments to key ministerial orders.
Here are the four main issues we are calling for to be resolved:
1. No requirement to ‘prove’ one’s status (the principle of self-determination)
Currently, in order to receive specific medical or social assistance intended for key groups, the system often lacks clear rules on how exactly to register such a person. As a result, in practice, people may be required to provide some kind of confirmation.
What we propose: to enshrine the principle of self-identification. We demand that the following rule be added to the criteria for determining the sex work group: ‘Persons are identified by their own self-determination or by applying for services aimed at this group. No institution or person may demand proof of the provision of sexual services in order to receive services’.
It is up to the individual to decide whether to disclose their status, and no one has the right to demand any ‘proof’ from them.
2. Protection of personal data
As sex work in Ukraine is still punishable under the Administrative Code, disclosure of one’s occupation can lead to problems with the police, blackmail or violence. The greatest fear among sex workers is that their relatives, neighbours or the police will find out about their work.
What we propose: to grant this data special status. In the amendments to the Ministry of Social Policy’s standards, we demand that the following be stipulated: ‘Personal data of individuals who provide sexual services, obtained in the course of social support, is subject to a higher level of protection. ‘Any disclosure of such data to third parties without the individual’s explicit written consent is prohibited.’
If you discuss your work with a social worker, you must be confident that this will remain between the two of you. This is a fundamental safeguard; without it, people will simply be afraid to seek help.
3. Stigma and rudeness
Very often, the barrier is simply the human factor — rudeness on the part of staff in hospitals or state centres. Being called offensive names (such as ‘prostitute’), receiving disparaging looks and being lectured cause people to avoid the formal healthcare system.
What we propose: specialised training for service providers. A mandatory rule must be enshrined in the regulations for hospitals and social service centres: “Professionals who directly provide services to people who provide sexual services must undergo training or education on non-judgemental approaches, the specific needs of this group, and the protection of confidentiality.”
Rudeness, ‘preaching’ and disrespect in state institutions must be a thing of the past.
4. Comprehensive healthcare instead of ‘just HIV tests’
We demand an expansion of the range of medical services. Sex workers must have easy access not only to HIV tests, but also to: free treatment for STIs; pre- and post-exposure prophylaxis; consultations with gynaecologists and other relevant specialists at convenient times, etc.
5. Support in crisis situations
Sex workers often face violence (both from clients and from law enforcement agencies).
We demand that sex workers be officially recognised as a group with priority access to social rehabilitation and crisis intervention services.
Why does this matter to everyone?
If you are not a sex worker and think this issue does not concern you — you are mistaken. Ensuring the rights of sex workers is a matter of health and safety for the whole of our society. When people have access to healthcare and protective measures, the spread of infections across the entire population is reduced. When the state protects the most vulnerable from violence, it becomes safer for everyone.
These proposals were formulated not by officials in offices, but by members of the community representatives themselves, based on real, often painful life experiences. The changes our community is proposing are not about privileges. They are about basic safety, respect for human dignity, and the right to be protected by one’s own state. These changes are a real way to make our lives safer here and now, even before the discriminatory article in the Administrative Code is fully repealed. When the state begins to see us as full citizens with a right to privacy, respect and quality healthcare - then society’s general attitude will change too.
Team of the CO “Legalife-Ukraine”
We continue to advocate for these changes. Share this article in your groups and on social media. Follow the news on our website to stay updated on how the process is progressing and how you can support our joint struggle for safety and rights! Together, we are making our rights visible!
Коментарів: 0